Goof Proof Brow Pencil Super easy brow-filling & shaping pencil
Estimated for this option and quantity. Sign in to earn at your tier. Final points follow the paid total after discounts; shipping and taxes do not earn points.
Goof Proof Brow Pencil is Benefit's answer to the problem that makes most people give up on brow pencils — a tip too fine to shape with and too hard to blend....
Authentic beauty · Shop with confidence
Need help with a shade or size? Ask SOFIEDelivery & returns
See our shipping policy for delivery times and availability.
Shipping policyReturn & refund policyTHE SOFIE GUIDE
How to use
Product videos and demonstrations.
Watch & learn
See how to apply and use Goof Proof Brow Pencil Super easy brow-filling & shaping pencil in tutorials from Benefit Cosmetics and beauty creators.
Watch tutorials on YouTube ↗About this product
Goof Proof Brow Pencil is Benefit's answer to the problem that makes most people give up on brow pencils — a tip too fine to shape with and too hard to blend. This one has a wide teardrop head that deposits shape in two strokes, a pointed edge for the tail, and a spoolie on the other end to soften it all. Twelve shades are available to match different hair colours.
What it actually does
- Shapes and fills in the same stroke. The custom teardrop tip is wide enough to lay down a brow shape, not just draw hairs.
- Glides without dragging. Benefit describes the colour as soft and glide-on, which is what keeps the result looking like brow rather than a drawn line.
- Blends with the built-in spoolie. Brushing through breaks up the deposit so the brow reads naturally full instead of blocked in.
- Holds through the day. An instrumental test on 20 panellists showed colour lasting up to 12 hours, per the brand.
- Waterproof. Benefit cites an instrumental test on 22 panellists confirming the colour as waterproof.
- Twelve shades. The range is built to flatter a spread of hair colours rather than forcing everyone into one brown.
- Brand study. In a consumer panel of 109 women after one week, 95% said filling and shaping brows was easy. Self-reported results.
How to use
- Use the wide side first. A couple of strokes from the inner start of the brow up to your arch builds the body of the shape.
- Switch to the point. Use the sharp edge of the tip to define the tail — the outer end needs precision the wide side can't give.
- Brush it through. Run the spoolie along the brow to blend the edges and settle the hairs into place.
- Layer if you want volume. A brow gel such as Benefit's Gimme Brow+ (sold separately) over the top adds the look of fullness.
Is it right for you?
Yes, if you…
- Want a defined, filled-in brow shape quickly
- Find ultra-fine pencils fiddly and slow
- Need something that survives heat and water
- Have sparse patches to fill rather than single gaps
Think twice if you…
- Want to draw individual hair strokes — the tip is broad
- Prefer a soft, barely-there brow
- Already have dense brows that only need brushing up
Questions
Which shade do I pick?
The range runs across twelve options to suit different hair colours. As a rule, go a touch lighter than your hair if your brows are already dark, and match your hair if they are sparse. Message us on WhatsApp with a photo in daylight and we will narrow it down.
Does it need sharpening?
The teardrop shape is the whole point of the tip — sharpening it into a cone would remove the wide edge you shape with. Keep the shape intact.
Will it come off in the pool or in summer sweat?
Benefit's instrumental testing on 22 panellists confirms the colour as waterproof, so it is a reasonable choice for hot weather. You will need an oil or balm cleanser to take it off properly.
Delivery time?
3 to 21 working days, depending on availability. If your shade is in stock it ships at the short end; a shade we order in for you takes longer. Working days exclude weekends and official holidays.
How do I pay, and can I return it?
Payment is by credit card, debit card, Instapay or mobile wallets — no cash on delivery. Returns apply to defective, damaged or expired items only, reported within 1 day of delivery. Verified refunds reach your original payment method within 15–30 days. Wrong shade is not covered, so do ask us before ordering.
VERIFIED SOFIE CUSTOMERS
Customer reviews
No SOFIE customer reviews for this product yet. Reviews from verified SOFIE customers will appear here.
THE SOFIE ROUTINE
Complete your routine
Chosen to work with this product: by category, brand and what is in stock today.
MORE TO DISCOVER
